Publications by Keith Goldfeld
Drawing the wrong conclusion about subgroups: a comparison of Bayes and frequentist methods
In the previous post, I simulated data from a hypothetical RCT that had heterogeneous treatment effects across subgroups defined by three covariates. I presented two Bayesian models, a strongly pooled model and an unpooled version, that could be used to estimate all the subgroup effects in a single model. I compared the estimates to a set of line...
5120 sym R (2688 sym/6 pcs) 2 img
Analyzing a factorial design by focusing on the variance of effect sizes
Way back in 2018, long before the pandemic, I described a soon-to-be implemented simstudy function genMultiFac that facilitates the generation of multi-factorial study data. I followed up that post with a description of how we can use these types of efficient designs to answer multiple questions in the context of a single study. Fast forward thre...
12553 sym R (4687 sym/14 pcs) 18 img
A Bayesian analysis of a factorial design focusing on effect size estimates
Factorial study designs present a number of analytic challenges, not least of which is how to best understand whether simultaneously applying multiple interventions is beneficial. Last time I presented a possible approach that focuses on estimating the variance of effect size estimates using a Bayesian model. The scenario I used there focused on ...
9365 sym R (5102 sym/8 pcs) 6 img
Sample size requirements for a Bayesian factorial study design
How do you determine sample size when the goal of a study is not to conduct a null hypothesis test but to provide an estimate of multiple effect sizes? I needed to get a handle on this for a recent grant submission, which I’ve been writing about over the past month, here and here. (I provide a little more context for all of this in those earlie...
5474 sym R (3972 sym/3 pcs) 4 img
simstudy update: adding flexibility to data generation
A new version of simstudy (0.3.0) is now available on CRAN and on the package website. Along with some less exciting bug fixes, we have added capabilities to a few existing features: double-dot variable reference, treatment assignment, and categorical data definition. These simple additions should make the data generation process a little smoothe...
4133 sym R (4290 sym/12 pcs) 4 img
The design effect of a cluster randomized trial with baseline measurements
Is it possible to reduce the sample size requirements of a stepped wedge cluster randomized trial simply by collecting baseline information? In a trial with randomization at the individual level, it is generally the case that if we are able to measure an outcome for subjects at two time periods, first at baseline and then at follow-up, we can red...
14999 sym R (5875 sym/23 pcs) 8 img 5 tbl
Exploring design effects of stepped wedge designs with baseline measurements
In the previous post, I described an incipient effort that I am undertaking with two colleagues, Monica Taljaard and Fan Li, to better understand the implications for collecting baseline measurements on sample size requirements for stepped wedge cluster randomized trials. (The three of us are on the Design and Statistics Core of the NIA IMPACT Co...
16759 sym R (6677 sym/12 pcs) 10 img 7 tbl
Controlling Type I error in RCTs with interim looks: a Bayesian perspective
Recently, a colleague submitted a paper describing the results of a Bayesian adaptive trial where the research team estimated the probability of effectiveness at various points during the trial. This trial was designed to stop as soon as the probability of effectiveness exceeded a pre-specified threshold. The journal rejected the paper on the gro...
13109 sym R (4286 sym/11 pcs) 6 img
Skeptical Bayesian priors might help minimize skepticism about subgroup analyses
Over the past couple of years, I have been working with an amazing group of investigators as part of the CONTAIN trial to study whether COVID-19 convalescent plasma (CCP) can improve the clinical status of patients hospitalized with COVID-19 and requiring noninvasive supplemental oxygen. This was a multi-site study in the US that randomized 941 p...
12112 sym R (8025 sym/17 pcs) 8 img 2 tbl
Including uncertainty when comparing response rates across clusters
Since this is a holiday weekend here in the US, I thought I would write up something relatively short and simple since I am supposed to be relaxing. A few weeks ago, someone presented me with some data that showed response rates to a survey that was conducted at about 30 different locations. The team that collected the data was interested in unde...
5520 sym R (4188 sym/12 pcs) 6 img 1 tbl